Smell
What our cheddar bites smell like, bag to pocket
Updated
Does freeze dried cheese smell? Ours does, and the honest description is that it smells like cheddar cheese. That is how we describe every bag of these bites. Where the smell ends up on a walk depends on how you carry the pieces, and we never use it to judge whether a bag is still good.
What do our cheddar bites smell like?
Like cheddar cheese. We keep it to those three words, and we use them for every bag. We will not rate it against fresh cheddar or against other treats, because we have no yardstick for that and would only be guessing.
What you are smelling is the cheese the bag lists. Printed on the bag, the ingredient list runs: pasteurized milk, cheese cultures, salt, enzymes. So when we say cheddar, we mean the plain thing: a dairy treat that smells the way its name suggests.
The cheddar itself comes from New York State. Our small batches of bites are made from it in Malvern, Pennsylvania, and they go out in an 8 ounce bag. Those are the only facts about its past that we claim, and none of them changes the one-line description above.
Where does the cheddar smell end up on a walk?
Wherever the cheese goes. Your fingers pick up a little cheddar each time you take out a piece, and they may carry it until you wash up. The pouch carries it too, and so does whatever pocket the pouch rides in. Any cheese treat smell in a pouch is simply the treat doing what it does.
We have no trick that removes it, and we will not make one up. What we can offer is a habit of our own: keep the session's pieces in one closed place that you choose. If the cheddar lives in a single pouch, you know where it has been, and you are not finding crumbs in three coat pockets next week.
Choosing the carrier is its own subject, and the guide to carrying training treats takes it step by step. If the smell has already settled into a pouch, how to clean a treat pouch is the page for that. This one only describes what the cheese smells like and where it goes.
Does the smell change once the bag is open?
We do not describe a change, so we will not say one happens. What we have is guidance for an opened bag. Our listing asks you to close the bag up again after each use and to store it somewhere cool and dry. The same listing says dried cheese does not need the fridge. Once it is open, our own guidance gives the bag thirty days.
A sniff is not how we would judge a bag. Go by two things instead: the printed best-by date, and the thirty days that start when you open it. How long freeze dried cheese lasts lays out those two dates in full.
Think of it this way: the smell is a description of the cheese, and the dates are the rules for the bag. Swapping the two is how a sensible routine turns into guesswork.
Why would a cheese smell matter in a training session?
From your side of the leash, mostly as a matter of housekeeping. The cheddar is on your fingers and in your pouch, so you are the one carrying it through the session. A short session keeps the bag in your hands for minutes, not an afternoon.
One practical line covers most of it. Keep the bag shut between repetitions, and bring a piece out only when you are ready to pay for something you just saw. Pieces that stay in the closed bag are pieces that stay where you put them.
Our freeze dried cheddar bites are rewards, handed out alongside your dog's meals and never in place of them. We make no claim about what the smell does for your dog. We describe what the cheese smells like to us, and the rest is for you to watch as you train.
Questions
Does the smell tell me whether the bites are still good?
No. We do not use smell for that, in either direction. Check the best-by date on the bag, and count thirty days from the day you open it, which is our guidance. Write the day you opened the bag on it, so the count is easy to follow.
Do the crumbs left in the bottom of a bag smell the same as whole bites?
They are the same cheese, so we describe them the same way: like cheddar cheese. Our listing says the bites crumble over kibble, so a crumb or two in the bag is within what the listing describes. Whole piece or crumb, our description does not change.
Will my fingers smell like cheddar after a session?
They may, until you wash up. A piece in your fingers means cheese on your fingers, and that is the whole story. We have no comparison to offer with other treats, only that plain fact and a pouch you can keep closed.
Do the bites smell of anything besides cheddar?
We describe the smell as cheddar cheese, and that is the only description we give. The bag prints four ingredients, pasteurized milk, cheese cultures, salt and enzymes, and we would rather leave it at that than add adjectives of our own.
Does every bag smell the same?
We describe every bag the same way, like cheddar cheese. That is all we say about it. We make no claim about how one bag compares with another, and we would rather you judge a bag by its printed date than by its smell.